Wednesday, 19 November 2014

First Nations and Second Class Citizens – Lessons from Australia

Having traveled, lived and worked in various parts of the world, Canada is by far one of the best countries on earth. Yet, my bubble keeps bursting the more I learn about the plight of aboriginal people and to realize that, I as an immigrant have more rights and opportunities than the First People makes me very sad. I am inspired to write this as I heard a memorable tribute by Australian Aboriginal Elder, Noel Pearson to their 21st Prime Minister, Gough Whitlam. I look forward to hearing an aboriginal tribute like this for a future Canadian leader.   His speech is accessed here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QDIc45eOILE
---------------------------------------------------------------
Noel Pearson
“One born estranged from the nation's citizenship, into a humble family of a marginal people striving in the teeth of poverty and discrimination, today it is no longer the case.  This because of the equalities of opportunities afforded by the Whitlam program”, said  Noel Pearson, Australian Aboriginal Lawyer and Activist, at Whitlam’s funeral eulogy on 5th November 2014 at Sydney Town Hall[i].

He went onto say why. “The achievements of this old man are present in the institutions we today take for granted and played no small part in the progress of modern Australia. Who can say that liberating the talents and uplifting the horizons of Australians for equality is not a worthy charter for national leadership? My chances in this nation were a result of the Whitlam program. I share this consciousness with millions of my fellow Australians whose experiences speak to the great power of distributed opportunity.” 

PM Gough Whitlam
What a prodigious tribute to Australia’s leader from 1972 to 1975 who in those tumultuous 3 years made sweeping reforms and programs that brought Australia into a new world. Among them were the Racial Discrimination Act, needs-based schools funding, the law reform commission, student financial assistance, non-discriminatory immigration rules, community health clinics, Aboriginal land rights which paved the way for  Native Title Act under Prime Minister Keating in 1993.

That was 3 years before the last residential school was closed in Canada.

Author James Daschuk at Ottawa Book Fest 
As I learn about Canada and its relationship with its first people, my “Canadian bubble” - my perception of what it means for me to be Canadian is being tested.  Another bubble burst as I sat at the Knox Presbyterian Church in Ottawa in a crowded room listening to James Daschuk about his book Clearing the Plains: Disease, Politics of Starvation, and the Loss of Aboriginal Life on 1st November 2014.
Daschuk’s emotional presentation spoke of the state-sponsored attack on indigenous communities whose effects continue to haunt us as a nation still.  

He spoke of the turning point for the plains people after the 1878 election of the John A MacDonald led Conservative government, which cut budgets and staff for Department of Indian Affairs including medical personnel. The opposition Liberals were no angels in this, as when they complained about the budget and spending, MacDonald is on record stating that the emergency rations would be refused until the “Indians” were on the verge of starvation. This was part of his plan to force the Aboriginal people off the plains onto reserves in order to settle the West and pave the way for the Canadian Pacific Railway.  
 
This chilling story of calculated callousness left me further confused about the contradictions of Canada. The divide between the First Nations people and non Natives, and the racism that drove those policies go largely unnoticed and unabated even today.  The political and social discourse perpetuated through education and the media makes us ignorant of this Canadian history.

The ultimate irony for Daschuk was receiving the Sir John A. Macdonald Prize from the Governor General a few days later.

Daschuk ended his talk by reflecting - “As we approach the 200th anniversary of Macdonald's birth, will these revelations about our first prime minister alter our perceptions of the man - and of ourselves as Canadians?”.  
 
Canadians have to face this history, not with guilt and defensiveness - as this happened long ago in another reality steeped in the settler notion of “Manifest Destiny” – a racial doctrine based on the god given right to expand land ownership, commercialism and Christianity by driving away aboriginal people off their land - but with the spirit of reconciling with the past and looking to the future to thrive in peaceful co-habitation.
The Canadian Charter for Rights and Freedoms Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau enacted in 1982 laid the groundwork for much social and political change for Aboriginal people and their rights today - including the Harper apology.  

Yet there continues to be political and bureaucratic inertia in settling land claims and other areas including funding inequalities in education and healthcare for Aboriginal communities for instance.  Many aboriginal leaders are fatigued and frustrated from legal battles and what a waste of people and resources for Canada.

Noel Pearson born in an Aboriginal reserve liberated his talents to have a fighting chance at equality only after the Australian government outlawed the institutionalized discrimination and the bureaucratic apparatus that controlled the reserves. Now they can hold their head up high in dignity and self esteem, as the laws of the land protects them, like every other citizen.  However, conditioning, attitudes and prejudices of the European Australians are slow to change.

There is an awareness of all this and a momentum mounting with the "Mainstream" who see Canada’s future clearly as a plural and multicultural nation. This includes honouring the First People’s historical significance on this land in the complex balance between inclusion and assimilation, and enabling the distinct nations to govern their own lands and people to flourish for mutual benefit. 
Acknowledging and Reaching Out

Tears welled up in me as I sat at the Carleton University’s 145th Convocation on 15th November 2014, as Master of Ceremonies and Vice Provost John Sheppard opened the ceremony acknowledging the Algonquin land we are occupying. Then he invited Metis elder Lois McCallum to recite the opening prayer who thanked the creator in gratitude for all we have and blessed the graduates for abundance of good things to come.  My emotions tugged at me as this gesture to acknowledge set an amazing example to those young graduates and their loved ones.

Most Canadians have an open and an inviting heart and according to John Ralston Saul, this is because everyone has some of the original Aboriginal Culture of welcoming to the circle. I know this from all my experiences here, even after coming through a traumatic introduction to Canada in the racially fraught 1970s.
                                                                                                                
Chelsea Mayor Caryl Green and friends walking to

Kitigan-Zibi
I celebrated this openness as I walked with my friends from Chelsea, Quebec to the Kitigan-Zibi Anishinabeg Reserve on 2nd November 2014. The walk was organized by Janet Intscher and Sue Bramley and with Chelsea Mayor Caryl Green on a beautiful autumn Saturday.
Eight months ago on 23rd March 2013, Chelsea residents, gave the Nishiyuu Walkers - the six Cree youth and two guides who walked 1,600 kms from the remote village of Whapmagoostui, Quebec on the shores of the Hudson Bay and their 200 plus supporters, among them from Kitigan-Zibi north of Chelsea - a rousing welcome at the Meredith Centre.  
Chelsea elder David Maitland recited a welcome poem at the well organized event coordinated by Helen Patterson, Robert Vandenberg and other community leaders. The centre was a hive of activity with entertainment and abundant sumptuous food served by Les Fougeres restaurant. That day, I heard many a visitor voice their surprise and delight at the warm welcome, which they said was the best they had on their long journey.
There was a perfect “aboriginal” storm brewing for Chelsea as it was around the same time that the Meredith Centre
Billy Diamond
Robert Chitty - Gordon Group
featured the documentaries produced by Robert Chitty of the Gordon Group, on the James Bay Cree’s, Billy Diamond and the band
(Eeyou Istchee) https://www.cngov.ca/press-november-10/   fight to protect the land from Quebec Hydro’s development.  

Chelsea was smitten by all this and decided to make a reciprocal gesture of reaching out, of listening and consulting their nearest First Nations community, which happens to be Kitigan-Zibi.  “We wanted to express our solidarity with them and to demonstrate in a concrete way that some people are indeed listening”, said Janet Intscher, as inspiration for the walk. 

Kitigan-Zibi Community Center Display
As Chelsea moves forward with with this journey with no grand plan to let things unfold, they are beginning to form friendships with the Anishinabeg people.  As an outsider and insider – I am intrigued and excited about the possibilities. It just may lead to bigger things - to succor and support the new friends in their struggle for respect, equality and balance by influencing the powers that be.


My reflections on the walk and the welcome to the Kitigan-Zibi reserve will be next.   



Stay tuned.

Meegwetch.