I write
this as I was smitten by America’s spirit since I was a child. Now to see it unravel saddens me.
As I learn the history of the USA, I
realize how the founding principles that were reinforced as a global superpower after World War
II as the benefactor and the policeman of the world - has changed to an overbearing empire - trying control the world in its own selfish interest.
Rather than bringing the world together - USA seems to be influenced by demagogic,
ideological politicians and advisors through 'American Exceptionalism' - dividing the world in its own
interest, ignoring that others too aspire to meet the same
basic human needs and more.
The sword
of Damocles hangs over the world with the Nuclear arsenal based on a technology
that metaphorically and in reality separates, as the destructive force comes from
splitting an atom. This contradicts our default mode as humans, which is communion as life begins with a union of two beings becoming vulnerable to each
other with trust.
Does that alone not
give us a clue of our true reality of interdependence and our oneness with nature?.
That is
why I write this personal reflection from the heart, based on my own experiences and inquiry
as an outsider with a keen interest - to provoke thought at this crucial time
for USA and the world.
--------------------------------
It is December
2020 and the United States of America is at cross-roads. It is not the first time this nation has
faced troubles and uncertainty, however this time a combination of challenges
and issues are converging, both at a global and local level that threaten the
nation.
It will take
an enlightened and a balanced political, civic, religious and corporate leadership to navigate
through this storm.
When I state
‘balanced’ - it is the ‘power of balance’ – to realize that MIGHT; whether it
is economic or military is not the way to dominate through these sensitive and complex
times. Doing as one pleases in a
globalized and informed world could end in tragedy.
What is
different this time, as opposed to times before, is that the USA then had enormous
amounts of power and resources to do its bidding around the world. "Washington Consensus" dominated the world after the cold war with its 'free market' ideology.
Today, with access to information and global economic power spread
among many nations in an interconnected world, that influence especially in a
'soft power' sense, has depleted.
In addition
to the distrust of the rest of the world, this time there are deep divisions
within and dysfunctional leadership that has decimated many of its own internal control
systems could lead to anarchy on their own soil.
That is why
sanity must prevail with a well-balanced leadership coming to the fore to bring
the nation together, as an implosion could impact the whole world.
My
Childhood Fascination with the USA
 |
My first toy car was American
|
I used to
look forward to two monthly outings with my father to the British Council and
United States Information Service (USIS) Library in Kandy, Sri Lanka back in
the 1960s. Somehow the US news reels were more exciting - full of glamour - the
ticker tape parades, big buildings, vast open vistas, fancy cars, sports arenas, huge tracts
of agricultural lands, large harvesting machines – in contrast to the staid BBC
reels even with the pomp and pageantry.
 |
Pinterest
|
 |
Ford Wagons - Pinterest
|
I used to
marvel at the colourful ads of happy families around Ford Station Wagons with curious 'wood paneling', the allure of Cadillacs and Lincolns with elegantly dressed people
in the National Geographic and Life magazines that came home every month.
 |
Sam Cooke Pic: Vint.ages
|
I was
smitten by America at a young age - even the music in my mother’s record
collection in the 1960s – Nat King Cole,
Sam Cook, Jim Reeves, Elvis (I did not know
of the racial issues at the time) as I listened to these over and over again in
her ‘His Masters Voice’ turn table.
Movies like Turning
Point with Clint Eastwood and his Dodge Hemi Charger,
 |
Bullitt Pic. New York Times
|
Steve McQueen’s Bullitt
and his Ford Mustang, the wild and crazy - Its a Mad Mad World made a
strong impression on me as I came upon my teens.
Even though
Sri Lanka’s austerity politics was more aligned with Soviet Russia, I was
converted to the allure of capitalism by these media influences before I was 10
years old.
Russia got ingrained in my
mind as an evil empire and the space race made this even more exciting. I remember being glued to radio in July 1969
as Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin set foot on the moon from Apollo 11 and
returning to earth – the exuberance was infectious I wanted a piece of that
action.
 |
Cousins Nedra and Harindra and their Tornado
|
My quest to
leave Sri Lanka started about that time, as our uncle Walter (Wally mama) – my
mother’s brother, Aunty Pansy and cousins Nedra and Harindra had moved to
Canada in 1963.
Seeing colour photos of their lovely home and the big Oldsmobile Tornado pulling a
camper over beautiful scenery seemed so idyllic, Canada became my destination
(as that was more realistic to get close to the USA). I would not let up on this quest until my
parents relented.
Arriving
in North America
We arrived
in Toronto, Canada on the evening of 13th November 1973. I recall sitting in the front seat of my
uncle Reggie’s (Raja mama) Chevrolet, reveling in a high speed ride from the
airport on the multi-lane Highway 401 marveling at the lit buildings that extended
to the sky – everything was such a stark contrast to the quiet hillside town of Kandy
- it was surreal.
As it snowed
the next morning and I went for a long walk along the Ellesmere Road in
Scarborough, it was everything I imagined – the vast spaces, the huge cars,
clean air, yet I was amazed there were hardly any people out and about.
As we were
settling in, I was beginning to understand the dynamics – the similarities and
the differences between Canada and the USA.
The first glimpse into American life came through the television – the
Brady Bunch, Green Acres, All in the Family with Archie Bunker, The Jeffersons,
Sanford and Son with Redd Fox, even the Flintstones cartoons gave me some
insights into the diversity and even the differences and nuances in American
society.
I was
intrigued by Irv Weinstein on channel 7 - WKBW TV - starting the nightly newscast with - “Its 11 o clock, do you know where your children are?”. I realized that Buffalo – the American city
across the Niagara Falls border seemed a stark contrast to Toronto for its
crime and homicides.
My first
trip across the border on a Greyhound bus to Cleveland via Buffalo in 1975
confirmed this contrast. I was surprised to see such poverty and disparity
in the country that I so admired from far.
In the affluent Cleveland neighborhood of Shaker Heights among my
mother’s pen friend Polly Fine’s family and friends, I realized the deep divide
between the have’s and have nots - where race also played a role in America.
The Pioneering
Nation of the United States of America
North America received hundreds of thousands of European settlers getting away from religious persecution and social
subjugation from the mid 1600s. These free people wanted to create a society
based on that very liberty they had acquired from venturing across the
Atlantic. This liberty based on
individualism bred self esteem, confidence - for many the protestant work ethic and a contentiousness that fueled an ambition to succeed over the overbearing
motherlands of Europe.
One of the founding fathers of the revolutionary republic of the United
States, English born
 |
Thomas Paine Pic: The Peacemakers
|
Thomas Paine painted a vision for America to move away
from the class-based system of England to the power of the people.
He decried
Britain’s 'Fiscal-Military State' where he stated “Britain’s reliance on war as
state craft created a vicious cycle of increasing debt and heavier taxes on the
common people and the mixed constitution of democratic, aristocratic and monarchical elements served that vicious cycle.”
He expected that America, with its
commercial population freed from the depredations of the British government,
would be different.[ii]
Eventually, ingenuity improved upon the industrial age developments of
Europe, especially in significant areas of steel production, electric power
generation and industrialized farming unhampered by a class system was
showcased to the world at the Chicago Exposition of 1893. America was emerging as a distinct,
swashbuckling free-spirited culture - it was exciting and contagious.
Two primary
blemishes that continues to be a drag on the nation is the history of the
stolen land from indigenous native Americans and African Slavery.
Notwithstanding
these, America forged ahead with a vision to dominate the world differently
from the colonial British.
Coming
out to the World: The Two Wars
World
War I brought America to the world stage, but it was World War II that
made a real difference in America’s attitude and dominance in the world.
Ironically, that started
with war time scientific joint innovation between the US and Britain when Prime
Minister Churchill dispatched the then Rector of the Imperial College Sir Henry
Tizzard in 1940 (The Tizzard Mission) to join with President Franklyn
D. Roosevelt’s team. The British were ahead in wartime technological developments
at the time.
American ingenuity took over and soon developed new technologies for the war including the
nuclear bomb.[iii]
President
Roosevelt who saw the nation revive from the 1929 economic depression had a
challenging task again as America grappled with the complex World War II. (Ref: "Untold History of the United States" documentary by Oliver Stone and Peter Kuznick).
There was a
delicate balance required to manage between communist Russia, Britain and its
allies with a mixture of ideologies to go against Nazism, Fascism and
Imperialism of the Germans, Italians and the Japanese. The US, Britain and the
Soviet partnership rose to the occasion and eventually led the way in beating
both Germany and Japan, yet the USA came out on top for several reasons.
In the end
Soviet Russia lost 27 million people to the US and Britain losing 500,000
each.
USA turned
the tide with huge strides in technology, weaponry (nuclear and the hydrogen
bomb) which changed the global stakes for humanity.
It would then become America’s responsibility
to ensure that the enormous power they gained was not misused. At the time, there was enlightened leadership
with Roosevelt and his Vice President, the spiritually intelligent Henry
Wallace who sort to create a middle ground and not dominate the world.
 |
Roosevelt and Wallace Pic. NY Times
|
Wallace was
a systems thinker - a farmer who also studied eastern philosophies and understood the human
mind and psyche – which to the average war monger meant a pacifist – a
weakling.
Ideologues
Take Over
Wallace was
eventually pushed out of the running for a second term with Roosevelt by hard
liners and hawks who looked at him as alien for his spirituality and
open-hearted worldviews. An unknown
Harry Truman was brought forward by the hardliners to which an ailing Roosevelt
caved in.
It was during Truman’s time the US
changed itself into a fiscal-war economy like Britain and created the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) to do its bidding overseas, especially as its
animosity with the Soviets grew to fuel the cold war. Truman was driven by zealots like the
Secretary of State James F Byrnes and James Forrestal (Secretary of the Navy),
Dulles brothers to become anti-Soviet wielding the power of Nuclear
weapons.
By this time, a war in Korea had
started to stop the communist expansion and US was exerting its power to take
control of the world. This led Soviet Russia to develop and test their own
nuclear bomb in 1949 fueling a nuclear arms race and the cold war.
 |
George Marshall
|
Leaders like former General George
Marshal (Marshal Plan) kept the US from going completely hostile to the world,
even as the likes of obsessive demagogic Senator Joseph McCarthy’s
anti-communist crusade attacked, as America forged a path of fear and
paranoia.
With
General Dwight Eisenhower taking Presidential office in 1952, USA had become
the technocratic anti-communist policeman of the world.
At
the end of his career Eisenhower’s conscience kicked in and spoke against the military industrial complex he
had helped to propel and consolidate.
It
was too late as the young John F. Kennedy inherited a militarized hawkish
nation which went to the brink of a nuclear Armageddon with the arch enemy
- Soviet Russia.
As President Kennedy battled with hawkish military generals like Curtis LeMay, the CIA Director Allen Dulles (later fired by him for the Bay of Pigs Cuban fiasco) and the likes of the self righteous head of the FBI - J. Edgar Hoover to find a middle path and a truce with the then Soviet
President Nikita Khrushchev - his position was in peril. Who knows which of his enemies got him at the
end in Dallas, Texas in November 1963 with USA losing a chance at a new more
peaceful direction for the world.
President
Johnson taking over was not a patch on Kennedy in his vision for a new world
order. He continued to fuel the fire in
another war to stop the communists in Vietnam.
If
only these American leaders had read the history of China. John Kaey’s book China: A History
chronicling 5000 years of history shows over and over how Korea and Vietnam
were never conquered.
That should have
given a clue to hawks like Kissinger and later Presidents Nixon that the
Vietnamese had a certain tenacity not even millions of tons of bombs dropped
from above could stop. Nixon ended this
losing war in 1973 which showed America that might and fire power cannot
overcome the human spirit.
 |
| About to depart on the Black River |
I
have seen with my own eyes in Vietnam, as I traveled by boat to
remote communities on the Black River reservoir of the Hòa Bình Dam during my time as a rural and renewable
energy consultant in the 1990s, large tracts of land bare of any vegetation
poisoned by Agent Orange sprayed by US warplanes between 1961 and 1971.
This was done to defoliate the land so the
Vietcong fighters could not find cover.
I also sadly came across so many families with deformed children in
these remote villages even 20 years later, with these stories generally unknown
to the world.[iv]
Even
the genial President Carter got caught up in promoting the military industrial
complex in his struggle with Iran and losing to President Reagan. Reagan
continued US's hegemonic politics advised by religious zealots like CIA’s William J.
Casey, continued to impose the American will in South America and the rest of the
world.
George
Bush Snr. continued on his military adventure in Iraq and Kuwait and later his
son George W took the cake after 9/11 in the biggest deception and lie to the
world.
The phantom weapons of mass
destruction (WMD) was concocted by the 'reptilian' threesome of Dick Cheney, Donald
Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz - even the genial Colin Powell was dragged in - along with oil industry executives and the British PM Tony Blair - hatched a plan to take over the oil fields and water
reservoirs of Iraq.
All
that backfired with US losing Iraq and the region to the likes of ISIS and other fundamentalist groups being unleashed, yet no one is brought to justice and no one even repents.
One
would think that this hawkish behaviour was republican alone, but Presidents
Clinton and Obama continued this crusade of US exceptionalism.
I
was so impressed by reading of Barack Obama’s humanity in his book – Dreams
of My Father where I thought America will change and so will the
world. I was too naïve and I presume -he
was too.
I
was so disappointed to hear there were ten times more air strikes in the covert
war on terror during President Barack Obama’s presidency than under his
predecessor, George W Bush.
Obama
developed the Military Drone program, making it worse than dropping bombs from
planes. They wreaked havoc from a safe control room far away with 563 strikes targeting
Pakistan, Somalia and Yemen during Obama’s two terms, compared to 57 strikes
under Bush. It is reported that over
1,000 civilians were killed in those countries, according to reports logged by
the Bureau of Investigative Journalism.[v]
President Trump
steered well clear of any costly new military blunders like the war in Iraq or
the 2011 Obama’s intervention in Libya.
Even some of Trump’s fiercest critics acknowledge that the
administration has notched some important foreign-policy successes—most notably
on China and in the Middle East.[vi]
However,
the drone warfare has continued on his watch too, but I doubt he has been kept
in the loop of what continues through the institutionalized system as a part of war against
terror.
Trump
did meet North Korea’s Kim Jong-un - which took
the mystery away of Jong-un's infallibility. Nothing
like sitting in front of a person for an
eyeball to eyeball conversation to neutralize a long-held animosity. Trump’s
efforts, in the eyes of the world, declawed Jong-un who seemed scary and
mysterious before.
Even
as erratic and emotionally unstable Trump seems, he has been less of a menace to
the rest of the world. He has in fact rattled the existing world order of
alliances like NATO and even put the UN on notice.
I
do not think Trump - the businessman's actions are politically strategic, but rather erratic - only focused on getting the best deal. His rhetoric and 'hubris' is confusing - perhaps an asset in a curated neo-liberal world - where he has to please his support base who voted for him to "drain the swamp".
Sadly he has separated and polarized the country to a dangerous "us vs them" mentality where it is difficult to have a conversation to find common ground.
Trump has gone through many advisors but has been consistent with Stephen Miller’s right wing, anti-immigration stance
(ironically grandson of Jewish immigrants from Russia).
Obama becoming the first African-American President drew a line across America. Trump has taken that line to a different level to separate America along racial lines.
Trump’s
actions are dividing the nation along the European origin Americans and
everyone else - starting from Native, African and Latin Americans, and others.
It is also dividing the nation along economic
lines, except many of his support base ironically are the ones that could get most hurt
by his erratic agenda - health care cuts, protectionist tariffs and tax relief to the rich.
America at Crossroads
At
the end of the day, as I look back at my own education on America, the America
that enamored me, that had me obsessed as a child to move closer to for all its
allure, the reality has set in that even great nations, that seemed infallible -
can fall.
The
United States of America is at crossroads – caught up in its own creation - a technocracy fueling a neo-liberal globalized world - to see that these economic policies have not
served its own people. Rather - it has
emboldened the free market and enriched a few people around the world making the gap even much
wider.
As Mark Carney, the former Governor of the Bank of England stated in his Reith Lectures on BBC on 2nd December 2020;
“How
we have come to esteem financial value over human value and how we have
gone from market economies to market societies… has contributed to a
trio of crises: of credit, Covid and climate.”
America led the way to create a consumerist world egged on by public relations gurus like Ed Bernays (author of the book Propaganda) at the turn of the 20th century where the market dictated and humans lost the plot to forget humanity.
They followed Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations in shaping a 20th century market society and forgot his book Moral Sentiments about human behavior based on ethics and values.
The Great Transformation
The
point of the story is that America and the world have to change from a
fiscal-war mongering economy to a more sustainable, stable one that does not
bring misery and mayhem to people of this world. That can only come from enlightened leaders
who will let go of the deluded, demoniacal, greedy focus on power and profits for America at the
cost of global human well-being.
Diffusing the Nuclear Threat
I
understand the need for America to build the nuclear bomb at the time as Hitler
was also moving in that direction. I am
so happy America got it at the time rather than Hitler, as he would have used it
liberally in his ego-maniacal madness to rule the world.
The onus was then on the guardians of the deadly technology. Nuclear arsenal should have been locked away soon after the war was over.
I even wonder whether the USA really had to use it
at the time in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, as by then the Japanese war machine was waning anyway.
The USA as the gracious victor - by putting the nuclear bomb away - could have followed a gracious path of world peace by building relationships,
especially with Russia.
Instead,
Russia lost the most (27 million people) fighting on the same side and ended up the enemy in an
unnecessary Cold War.
Ill
advised, Truman went the jingoistic ideological route without getting the
potential adversary close to him. Rather
than continue to cultivate a relationship with the insecure Stalin - Truman
alienated him.
Millions
more people died in the next 40 years around the world with the ripple effects of
USA’s anti-communist fear based global politics and the cold war.
To add to that, the nuclear bomb is in the hands of many more nations - India,
Pakistan, Israel, China, Iran, North Korea and others pitching humanity
into a perilous state.
Imagine
how the world would be different if the Marshal Plan to resurrect Germany and
Japan included Soviet Russia (to stay close to the potential adversary/enemy as done with Germany and Japan) – the world would not have such a wasteful nuclear
arms race and put the entire planet at risk of Armageddon.
America can still lead the way to a new kinder, gentler world order;
 |
Navy Pier - Chicago
|
America
– you defined the 20th century, gave the world a lot of things to
celebrate for, but there was a price to pay in the old model - as it was 'hubristic' with American exceptionalism based on a 'manifest destiny'. These are not aligned with the natural laws of the universe.
It is time now to realize that there is a
world of people out there who aspire for the same - to live happily, to love
their children and hope for their best and to die in peace - as we are equal in
birth as we are in death.
America - you
still have the power to change the paradigm to move away from this notion of exceptionalism and being a Fiscal-Military state - warring around the world with diminishing returns.
America's founding principles - all political power emanate from the people and people have
fundamental rights of liberty, free speech, freedom of religion,
due process of law, and freedom of assembly - which gives rise to the American dream. That is not only an American dream - it is a universal dream for most human beings on this planet.
The economic collapse of 2008 was a call to action on the free market; electing of President Trump was a call to action by a disenfranchised people; Black Lives Matter is a call to action for ridding institutionalized racism and equal opportunity and finally COVID - is a call to action by Mother Nature - as that is a biological response to an ecological crisis that threaten all of us.
Some Humble and Idealistic Thoughts as a keen Observer
I have been told over and over again that Idealism and Capitalism do not mix. I do not agree.
The UN's Sustainable Development Goals <https://sdgs.un.org/goals> are both idealistic and pragmatic. SDGs are a good place to start as we find that balance or else Mother Nature will find homeostasis on this earth without us.
I also realize that hardened institutionalized structures and worldviews over the last 150 years cannot be wished away overnight. Change has to be paced and sequenced. COVID has shown us that we can adapt, so there is an opportunity.
America still is the most influential and powerful nation in the world (it may soon change and everyone has to come to terms with that too).
America - by moving away from a military industrial technological model to accept the emerging multi-polar world - rallying the world together - has an an opportunity to set in motion some fundamental changes needed in order to create a kinder gentler planet.
I am going to be audacious and put these thoughts out there as a wish-list to consider as I resonate with Martin Luther King Jr. when he said something like - "Our lives begin to end when we keep silent about things that matter".
Here are my thoughts and ideas to ponder on;
1. Move away from the fossil fuel economy, hence temper the alliances and interfering with oil producing countries, especially in the Arab world. Move towards a renewable energy economy.
2. Move away from the Fiscal-Military economy run by an inanimate technocracy and jingoistic politics - foisting liberal democracy to the rest of the world through the barrel of a gun. Redirect those funds to education, healthcare, institutional and social structures for well-being of the people instead of guns. Work towards global agreement to stop the Nuclear arms race.
3. Transform education policies to become inclusive as every citizen is an asset to the nation. Move towards a more introspective education for self awareness and a critical thinking learning process to complement teaching of economics, math, sciences and IT.
Provide creative arts, sports programs, martial arts, mindfulness and yoga (call them different names - breathing, stretching and calisthenics) and more inquiry based experiential learning in the curricula. This helps put perspective and context to realize the learner's place in the world, builds character acknowledging their humanity and oneness with nature.
Action research and inquiry based learning raises self-awareness, esteem and confidence so the new generation gains inner strength and power to think critically and take responsibility for themselves.
Work in partnership with parents as allies to the education system.
4. Slow the globalization in the production of goods and rebuild local production capacity and economies.
5. Rethink the limited liability corporation (an inanimate entity which can bribe and influence politicians to favor them over the people) - to a more socially responsible charter for businesses. Redesign the stock market to move away from quarterly profits - to a more robust way of measuring real value of companies. Regulate the stock market away from operating as a casino.
6. Encourage organic farming and sustainable agricultural practices to protect trees, land, soil and water. Listen to and learn from the Native Americans about living as one with nature.
7. Change the narrative, policies and funding for War on Crime; War on Drugs; War on Terror, which are inherently violent and costly - rather fund local and global initiatives to solve the root causes of these issues.
8. Encourage the media to use positive psychology and appreciative narratives in stories. Democratize the media from the current 5 corporations - to let go of control and biased political narratives that polarize the nation. Bring back the true spirit of journalism that holds anyone accountable.
9. Curtail political patronage - lobbying and influence of big pharma, big food, big oil, big-agro and arms monopolies which hurt people and the environment and not accountable to any.
10. Decouple the profit-based unholy alliance between big pharma and health insurance - to open up the health-care system to be holistic - to marry Allopathy and natural approaches for good health and well-being.
11. Move away from the narrative of American Exceptionalism. Create global alliances to cooperate on the environment (honour the Paris COP agreement), preservation of forests, natural habitat and water; on poverty; healthcare and well-being; education; technology development, space exploration and many other shared issues that need global cooperation with an open mind.
12. Elect emotionally and spiritually intelligent political leaders who speak to these transformations - leaders who understand the power of balance - in 2020.
Leaders finding the Power of Balance
America was founded on the Protestant ethic of hard work and discipline ennobling the individual certain rights and freedoms. However, prudence, integrity, humility, simplicity and community were also a part of this Puritan foundation.
All that got lost as consumerism appeared in the 20th century's modern techno-industrial complex. Hard work and discipline were combined with unfettered growth, greed and profit at any cost as corporations define political, social and economic agendas.
The new generation of political leaders can take back the power and influence from corporations driven by markets - to hand the power to the people, to govern in the spirit of those founding fathers as they intended in July 1776.
That requires the captains of industry to become mindful, as the human being is wired in default-mode for empathy and fairplay - to become aware of nature's laws and all of humanity's basic needs to live well. It does not mean, we stop innovating and trying to conquer the universe, as that is the human spirit.
With all the resources and ingenuity we have, there is no reason for a single human being on this planet to starve or live without dignity. For that, we have to preserve our planet's ecosystem too, as we are all one.
If America is able to find that 'power of balance' - and I see this being played out as the US Supreme Court stacked with republican judges ruled the 2020 election free and fair - through an independent judiciary, a solid bureaucracy and enlightened political leadership - it can anchor the nation to lead the way in partnership with other countries to flourish in a new world order for 2021 and beyond.
God bless America to help forge a kinder gentler and a more resilient world for the 21st century.
The story was also inspired by Oliver Stone's "The Untold History of the United States" documentary series.
[i]
https://www.wired.co.uk/article/manhattan-project-robert-oppenheimer
[ii]
Tom Paine’s Iron Bridge: Building a United States; Edward G. Gray; pp 119-123
[iii]
Let the Cat Turn Round: Alexander King p 119
[iv]
http://www.ipsnews.net/1999/05/thailand-toxic-legacy-of-the-vietnam-war/
[v]
https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2017-01-17/obamas-covert-drone-war-in-numbers-ten-times-more-strikes-than-bush
[vi]
https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/10/14/trump-foreign-policy-wins-losses-over-four-years-china-middle-east-coronavirus-pandemic/